By: Ofir Yossef Cohen Touval | Path of Living Waters
Why do people who practice spirituality for years feel that nothing has really changed in their lives – and what does the wisdom of Kabbalah say must be done differently?
In the modern era the word "spirituality" has become a wide-open field under which many and varied threads gather. There is a kernel of truth in this field – a genuine longing of the soul for its root, a sincere search for meaning, a sense that this cannot be all of reality. That kernel must not be dismissed.
And yet, the true seeker who wants to go through a process of deep change needs to distinguish between two approaches that differ at their root: what is sometimes called modern "spiritualism," and Jewish spirituality rooted in the wisdom of Kabbalah. The difference between them is not only semantic. It touches the most fundamental question of a person's life: is spirituality meant to serve me, or am I meant to change in order to serve the truth?
1. "If it feels good – it's right"? Not exactly
Modern spiritualism rests on subjective experience. Its central measure is the feeling: "If it feels right and pleasant to me – it's a sign that it's good." It is an approach with no commitment to structure, in which a person chooses ideas from different methods according to personal taste and assembles for themselves a kind of personal "spiritual menu."
The problem is that the universe is not a restaurant. Spiritual reality is built on precise laws, just as physical reality is built on laws of nature. You can decide that you don't "believe" in gravity, but if you jump out of the window – the law will act on you in any case.
Jewish spirituality rests on objective lawfulness. Reality is built in a precise structure of light and vessel; there is a Creator, there is creation, and there are fixed spiritual laws that govern the connection between them. In this approach, not everything that feels like "light" is in fact light. Sometimes a feeling of pleasantness is only a temporary gratification of the ego, while difficulty and effort are precisely the evidence of real growth.
2. When the ego wears a cloak of light
In spiritualism, the ego tends to undergo only a change of clothing. A person may feel "special," "illuminated" or "connected," but without going through a real process of clarification and self-purification. This is the state that Kabbalah calls a "kelipah of holiness" – a spiritual wrapping that hides an ego still acting from a self-centered place. Precisely because it is dressed in light, this kelipah is more dangerous than an open ego: it gives a person the feeling that they are already repaired, and so blocks them from the work of tikkun itself.
In Jewish spirituality, the ego – the will to receive for oneself alone – is the focus of life's work. It is not cancelled; it is repaired.
This is a process of equivalence of form: changing the will from self-reception to bestowal and giving. It is a process that is sometimes painful, demanding inner truth and a willingness to break the old in order to build a new vessel.
3. You cannot be your own teacher
Here perhaps lies the sharpest practical difference. Spiritualism is, at its foundation, non-binding. A person is their own teacher, choosing a bit from here and discarding a bit from there, and is not bound by any framework that goes beyond their momentary will. The price of this freedom is that there is no protection whatsoever against the mistakes of the ego itself – the very ego that is steering the whole choice.
Jewish spirituality requires belonging to a chain of transmission: kabbalah (receiving) from a teacher, dedication to halachah, humility before someone greater than you, and setting aside personal will before a tradition that is greater than you. Not because the individual is unimportant, but because precisely this self-nullification is the only vessel that allows the will to undergo real tikkun. The ego cannot purify itself. It must yield to something greater than itself.
4. The real test is not in meditation – it is in your relationship
Spiritualism often seeks experiences of rising above reality – an escape from everyday difficulties into spaces of imagined calm. Moments of elevation in meditation, in a workshop, on a retreat.
Jewish spirituality is measured precisely within matter and reality. The spiritual test is not in an isolated meditation on a mountaintop, but in the way a person acts within their relationship, at work, with money and in situations of pressure. There, in the friction of life, are found the sparks that need clarification.
The Arizal taught that souls descended to this world precisely in order to clarify the sparks that fell into the kelipot – and this clarification happens within life, not above it.
5. A spirituality that asks the wrong question
The goal of spiritualism is usually personal: healing, balance, reaching a state of "feeling good." The goal of Jewish spirituality is devekut (cleaving) to the Creator – connection to the root of life through inner change.
Spiritualism asks: "What will make me feel good right now?" Jewish spirituality asks: "What is the truth, and what is required of me in order to change?"
The disappointment that awaits every spiritual seeker – and what to do with it
For all its beauty, spiritualism carries within it a seed of disappointment. The seeker who has been trained to think that the universe will "send" them what they asked for, or that love broadcast to the whole world will change their fate, will discover sooner or later that life does not work that way. That the difficulty returns, the pain returns, the flaws of character return – and the short moments of elevation have become a distant memory that does not protect them in the hours of truth.
A real change in one's inner experience over the long term does not come from a change of feeling, but from a change of vessel. It comes from studying the spiritual system and its laws, from internalization over many years, and from consistent character work that slowly replaces the will to receive for oneself with the will to bestow. This is the only path that has proven itself over generations – not as a technique, but as an actual road.
Questions for inner reflection
To know where you truly stand, you need to look inward with complete honesty and ask the following questions:
- The motive for the work: Is my spiritual search meant to make me feel more comfortable and calm with myself, or to help me become a more giving and better person toward those around me?
- The test of difficulty: When a difficulty appears in my life (a conflict, a disappointment, pain), is my first reaction to look for a "spiritual technique" to escape the feeling, or do I try to understand what spiritual law is at work here and what I need to repair within myself?
- Truth versus comfort: Am I willing to take on a truth that contradicts my immediate wishes, or do I "choose" only the spiritual parts that fit my current lifestyle?
- Responsibility versus experience: Does my spirituality amount to moments of elevation and passing experiences, or is it expressed in daily commitment and consistent change of character within gray reality?
- The vessel and the light: Am I busy only inviting more "light" into my life (knowledge, feelings, energies), or am I investing most of my effort in building the "vessel" – in repairing my character traits and my will?
- The essence of the offering: The Hebrew word for an offering, korban, comes from the root "to draw near." What am I truly willing to "offer" – to give up part of the ego, a holding-back habit, the need to be personally right – in order to merit real closeness to the light?
This article is meant for those who are not content with managing their feelings, but seek a real tikkun within reality.
📖 The book in English (Amazon) | 🎥 YouTube | 💬 Daily WhatsApp updates (Hebrew) | 🎧 Spotify | ✍️ Blog
Loved it? ❤️ Share it so others can read it too.
The soul is thirsty. The path begins within.
A journey of healing that unites clinical psychology with the wisdom of Kabbalah and Chassidut – for anyone who feels that pain is a letter from the soul, asking us to return to our source.

