The Article Library

,

Spiritual or Psychological Therapy – What Is Right for You?

Spiritual or psychological therapy? The Rema teaches that the greatest wonder of creation is the binding of the soul to the body – and that…

אדם יושב בכורסה בחדר טיפולים חם, מול חלון הפתוח אל חומות ירושלים ומגדל דוד בשעת שקיעה, ובמדף ספרי קודש ונר דולק

By: Ofir Yossef Cohen Touval | Path of Living Waters

By: Ofir Yossef Cohen Touval | Path of Living Waters

Friends, almost everyone who comes into my therapy room asks, at some point, the same question: "Do I need a psychologist – or something spiritual?" They ask it as if these were two separate stores, and all they have to do is choose which one to walk into.

After more than three decades as a clinical psychologist, a homeopath, and a student and teacher of the inner dimension of the Torah, I have learned that the question itself already reveals where the difficulty lies. Not in the choice between two methods, but in the separation we have made inside ourselves between the psyche and the soul. And whoever seeks to revive their soul from the troubles of the material world must first of all mend that separation.

"And Performs Wonders" – the wondrous bond between spirit and matter

Every morning, Jews recite the blessing Asher Yatzar (the blessing of thanks for the body's functioning), which ends: "Healer of all flesh, who performs wonders." The Rema (Rabbi Moshe Isserles, the great 16th-century halakhic authority, Orach Chaim 6:1) explains that the wonder is that God binds something spiritual to something physical – a soul inside a body. This is the greatest miracle of creation, and within it lies the root of every illness and every healing.

When this bond loosens, a person feels it on every level: in a heart that pounds at night, in a body that tightens, in thoughts that keep repeating, and in a vague sense that life is passing them by. The symptom is only the place where the disconnection becomes visible.

Nefesh, ruach and neshamah – three layers, one person

The wisdom of Kabbalah teaches that three main layers operate within a person: nefesh (the vital soul), which dwells in the liver and the blood – life force, basic emotions, needs and fears; ruach (the spirit), which dwells in the heart – the world of character traits, feeling and relationships; and neshamah (the higher soul), which dwells in the mind – understanding, meaning, the direction for which we came down into the world.

Modern psychology works very well in the layers of nefesh and ruach. It gives language to emotion, brings order to a personal story, identifies patterns formed in childhood and teaches tools for coping. This is important work, at times lifesaving, and I do not belittle it for a moment – it is my profession.

But there are people who understand themselves well, who know exactly where a pattern came from, and still something in them does not calm down. The reason is simple: they have worked on the vessel, but have not asked what light is seeking to enter it. This is where the spiritual work begins.

When psychological stability must come first

Maimonides writes (Laws of Character Traits 2:1) that those whose souls are ill should go to the sages, "who are the healers of souls." But the same Maimonides was also a physician, and he knew that you do not build a second story on a shaking foundation.

When a person is in acute emotional flooding, active trauma, dark thoughts or a sense of losing control, the first step is a professional, stable and safe framework. This is not giving up on the spirit; on the contrary, it is protecting the vessel so that, in time, it can receive light. A great light that enters a vessel that is not ready breaks it. This is the secret of shevirat ha-kelim (the "breaking of the vessels" in the Kabbalah of the Arizal), and it is also a simple clinical truth.

When the difficulty is a call of the soul

Some crises are not only psychological but existential. A person is successful, functioning, has even "done therapy" – and still feels empty. The anxiety returns without a clear cause. The body speaks in pains that medical tests cannot explain. The question is no longer "What happened to me?" but "What am I here for?"

Baal HaSulam (Rabbi Yehuda Ashlag, the 20th-century Kabbalist) teaches that the human being was created as a "will to receive," and as long as this will is directed only toward itself, it will never be filled. You can heal a pattern, but if you do not change the direction in which the will flows, it will simply find itself a new pattern. In such places, the spiritual approach is not a nice extra – it is the heart of the healing.

When the psyche and the soul meet – healing the whole person

"He heals the brokenhearted and binds up their sorrows" (Psalms 147:3). Notice: God is both the healer and the one who binds up. He treats the break – and also the sorrow that remains after it. This is what real therapy should look like.

In my work, psychological tools and the insights of the inner Torah are not two worlds. They are two hands of the same body. You can understand a fear – and also ask what tikkun (inner repair) it invites. You can identify a pattern formed with your parents – and also see in it the raw material the soul chose to work with. You can listen to pain in the body – and also hear the deeper language it speaks.

In the Path of Living Waters clinic, this approach takes a very practical form: a combination of emotional understanding, tools for changing patterns, attention to the connection between body and psyche, and a spiritual anchor drawn from the wisdom of Kabbalah and Chassidut. Not as an ornament of ideas, but as the basis for deep and precise work at the root.

So how do you know what is right for you?

Don't only ask "Which method is better?" Ask yourself three questions:

Am I stable enough? If not – begin with stabilization, with safe professional support.
Do I understand myself – and still not change? The vessel is probably ready, and what is missing is direction.
Is my body already speaking? Pain, fatigue, a tight chest – these are signs that the disconnection between the layers has already descended into the physical.

A good therapist will not rush to fit you into a template. They will listen, assess the depth of the difficulty, and build a path that suits you – sometimes more psyche, sometimes more soul, and usually both together.

"Open for Me an Opening the Size of a Needle's Eye"

Our Sages say in God's name: "Open for Me an opening the size of a needle's eye, and I will open for you an opening as wide as a great hall" (Song of Songs Rabbah 5:2). You do not have to know all the answers in advance. It is enough to ask the right question: not only how to make the pain disappear – but what the pain is seeking to reveal. Not only how to get back to functioning – but how to come back to yourself.

If part of you feels that the present difficulty is not a random malfunction but a call, do not rush to silence it. It may be exactly that needle's eye – the small opening through which living waters begin to flow into your life.

📖 The book in English (Amazon) | 🎥 YouTube | ✍️ Blog

Now available in English
Path of Living Waters
The book by Ofir Yossef Cohen Touval
Cover of the book Path of Living Waters by Ofir Yossef Cohen Touval

The soul is thirsty. The path begins within.

A journey of healing that unites clinical psychology with the wisdom of Kabbalah and Chassidut – for anyone who feels that pain is a letter from the soul, asking us to return to our source.

YouTube videos are in Hebrew

Continue Reading

Back to the Article Library